Active ListeningBasic Listening

Why Basic Listening is often not enough

Read the article

Summary of the original

The Gordon Model teaches two kinds of listening: Basic Listening and Active Listening. Basic Listening helps the other person start talking and feel accepted. But the article argues this is often not enough, because the speaker still has no proof that you understand them. Active Listening fills that gap, and also helps the other person solve their own problem.

Original article · 01

What the original article says

  1. Basic Listening includes Attending, Silence, Door Openers and Acknowledgment Responses.
  2. Four limits of Basic Listening: there is little interaction, the speaker does not know whether you accept or reject them, it does not help them dig deeper into the problem, and it gives no proof that you have understood.
  3. Active Listening means saying back what you understood, so the other person knows you are listening and you can check whether you understood correctly.
  4. Four reasons to use Active Listening: people who solve their own problems become more capable and self-reliant; they have more information than an outsider; if your solution fails, you are seen as responsible; and if your solution succeeds, it does not help them become confident and independent.
Perspective · 02

A nod does not yet mean understanding

An employee knocks, sits down and tells you about something that is troubling them. You put down your phone, look at them, nod, and now and then say "uh huh" or "and then what?" Five minutes later you say: "OK, I get it. Here's what you do." They leave with a face not much lighter, and the next week the same problem comes back in a different shape.

In the L.E.T.® book, Dr. Thomas Gordon describes communication as a process with two ends. The speaker picks words to package what is going on inside them, and the listener has to decode those words to guess what the speaker really feels. Communication is complete only when what the listener understands matches what the speaker meant, and according to Gordon, that match is far rarer than we think.

Perspective · 03

Why understanding is hard

Gordon lists many reasons, and I picked four that managers meet every day. People are not always comfortable saying directly what they want, especially to the boss. Sometimes they cannot yet name their own feelings. The same word means different things to different people. And the listener is often busy drafting a reply in their head, so they hear only half the sentence.

The three things you did in those first five minutes, inviting the person to talk, staying quiet so they could speak, and the "uh huh" and "really?", are all necessary. Gordon calls them Door Openers, Passive Listening and Acknowledgment Responses. But all three only show that you want to understand. They give the speaker no proof that you have understood correctly.

Perspective · 04

Proof that you understand

Active Listening fills exactly that gap. The method sounds simple: you say back, in your own words, what you understood of the other person's feelings and meaning, so they can confirm or correct it. An example: an employee complains, "I don't even know what this report is for," and you reply, "You feel it's a lot of work and you're not sure anyone reads it." You do not advise or explain why the report exists. You simply put on the table what you heard.

It is simple in form but hard to master, because it runs against a lifetime habit of talking, advising and judging. Gordon notes that most L.E.T.® participants reach a moderate level of skill after a few weeks of deliberate practice.

Perspective · 05

Why not rush to a solution

Michelle Adams's piece gives four reasons, and the book explains the basis of the first two. First, letting the other person solve the problem is an investment, because they become less dependent and more self-reliant. Second, managers rarely know enough about another person's life and work to find the right answer.

The other two reasons share a root: when you hand over the solution, responsibility shifts from the person with the problem to you. If the solution fails, the employee says "I did exactly what you told me," and if it works, all they learn is to go to the boss whenever something comes up. Over 18 years as an entrepreneur and 7 bankruptcies, I have found that a desk piled with other people's problems is one of the fastest ways to wear a manager out.

Chapter 5 adds one more reason: the first thing people bring up is often just the outer layer. Gordon compares human problems to an onion that has to be peeled layer by layer to reach the core, and calls that outer layer the presenting problem. An employee who complains that "customers are so difficult lately" may actually be worried about having shifts cut.

Answer the first sentence right away, and you solve a problem that does not exist.

Perspective · 06

Not for every moment

The book is clear about several limits, and I find new learners often skip them.

  • You do not need to respond to every sentence. Sometimes silence or an "uh huh" is enough.
  • When an employee needs information or resources only you have, such as whether there is budget left, just answer. Gordon calls this legitimate dependency, and Active Listening is out of place there.
  • When you are in the middle of something urgent, or honestly not calm enough to listen, say so plainly and set another time. Gordon calls this the full cup principle: you cannot pour for anyone from an empty cup, and people notice right away when you only pretend to listen.
  • Some problems still need you to act after listening, such as moving someone's desk or asking for more staff. Listening helps clarify the problem, and solving it at that point is your job.
Perspective · 07

Understanding is not agreeing

"You feel really stuck" is very different from "I think this is a dead end too." The first accepts that the other person's feelings are real, while the second agrees with them. Many managers fear that if they listen closely, employees will think they agree. In reality, people are rarely accepted like that, so once they feel accepted, they often rebalance their own feelings.

Perspective · 08

Reflection questions

  1. In your most recent conversation with an employee, who offered the first solution?
  2. Have you ever said back what you understood and heard "yes, that's exactly what I mean"?
  3. How many of the problems on your desk really belong to someone else?

Reading gives you understanding, but turning it into a habit takes practice with someone guiding you. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, gives you enough practice time for exactly this.

This skill can be learned

An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.

Read next

All articles