Democratic valuesI-Message

Do you do what we say?

Read the article

Summary of the original

The article argues that many people live in political democracies but never learned democratic habits at home, at school or at work, so they repeat how they were treated and use power to make others comply. It lists the signs of undemocratic and democratic behavior, along with ten statements for self-assessment.

Original article · 01

What the original article says

  1. Democratic behavior takes skills that can be learned: self-awareness, self-responsibility, self-disclosure, empathic listening, cooperation, problem solving and conflict resolution.
  2. Eight undemocratic signs, for example: using power to force compliance, punishing with words or physical force, getting your way at others' expense, either winning or giving in during conflict, and imposing your own values.
  3. Twelve democratic signs, for example: narrowing the power gap, stating feelings and needs clearly with I-Messages, saying "no" when needed, listening without judgment through Active Listening, finding solutions both sides can accept, and respecting values different from your own.
  4. The article concludes that Gordon began bringing this model to people 64 years ago, and that each person who learns and uses these skills adds a piece to democracy.
Perspective · 02

The uncomfortable question in the title

Linda Adams's piece points out that many people are taught fine values about respect and equality but never got to practice those habits at home, at school or at work. So when they gain power, they repeat exactly how they were treated: using power to make others comply. I want to bring the discussion back to your own desk, and to how you make decisions with your team every day.

Perspective · 03

How power works

In Chapter 8 of the L.E.T.® book, Dr. Thomas Gordon defines power very simply: the ability to reward or punish others. He names two conditions for power to work. First, the people under you must depend on you, meaning they need something you control and cannot easily find it elsewhere. Second, they must fear that you really will punish them if they do not comply.

From this Gordon points to a paradox: few managers want a team that is both dependent and afraid, yet that is exactly what power needs in order to work. He also notes that in the U.S., the power gap between bosses and employees has narrowed because of unions, because workers can change jobs easily, and because training new hires is costly. In Vietnam, I see the "easy to change jobs" factor arriving fast among young workers, so the ground for using power is wearing thin too.

Perspective · 04

The cost that never shows up in reports

Gordon devotes many pages to the cost of using power, and I think this is the part Vietnamese managers should read most carefully.

First, information stops flowing upward. Employees hesitate to report problems because they know the boss will impose a one-sided solution, or because they fear blame. Information that does flow up gets filtered until only what the boss wants to hear is left. Managers who use a lot of power often complain that "nobody tells me anything," and Gordon says that is a consequence, not a coincidence.

Second are the ways the people below learn to cope. Some curry favor and become yes-men. Some compete with colleagues by blaming them and talking behind their backs. Some do exactly what they are assigned and nothing more. Gordon tells of a foreman who knew a part was being assembled backward and reported it, but nobody listened, so he simply followed orders and only made sure he was not around when it was discovered. Some resist openly, and some groups quietly set their own standard of "a fair day's work" to protect themselves, mocking anyone who goes beyond it. Last comes withdrawal: silence in meetings, avoiding the boss, then quitting.

Third is the cost to the manager: time. When a decision is handed down and people do not truly accept it, you have to explain, remind and monitor, like a police officer. Gordon quotes a company president he consulted for: he used to be proud of deciding fast, but later realized he spent ten times as long overcoming resistance as he had spent making the decision.

And the greatest irony: the more power you use, the less influence you have.

People act out of fear or need, not out of belief.

Perspective · 05

Authority is not power

The article lists signs of respectful behavior, including narrowing the power gap, stating your needs clearly with I-Messages, listening without judgment, and finding solutions both sides can accept. Gordon calls that approach the No-Lose Method.

I want to head off one misunderstanding: giving up power does not mean giving up authority. Gordon draws a clear line. Authority that comes from expertise, from a job description, or from agreements both sides have signed is legitimate. Only authority based on rewards and punishment carries the costs above. You still hold final responsibility, you still have decisions that belong to your role alone, and your needs must be met too.

Perspective · 06

An illustrative example

Mai, who manages a sales team of eight, changed how customers were split by region and announced it at the Monday morning meeting. No one objected. Three weeks later, sales in two regions fell. A new employee said what the whole team had known from the start: those two regions had loyal customers tied to the previous reps. No one had said it in the meeting, because Mai's meetings had never been a place to say "no".

Perspective · 07

Reflection questions

  1. In the past month, was there a decision you handed down, only to learn later that your team had seen the problem coming?
  2. When did someone last say "no" to you in a meeting?
  3. If you took two weeks off, which work would stall because no one dared to decide?

The original article has ten self-check questions; you can find them through the link to the original at the end of the page. If you want to practice solving problems so that nobody loses, an L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, is where I would suggest.

This skill can be learned

An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.

Read next

All articles