Summary of the original
Every group needs someone to lead it, and that person's attitudes and behavior affect the group's performance, ideas, energy and engagement. Many people step into leadership without being prepared. The author argues that when leaders are frustrated, the cause is almost always their own ineffectiveness.
What the original article says
- A familiar example: a strong technical expert gets promoted but does not know how to lead.
- Four questions about new leadership: do you find the role worth doing, do you feel successful, do you meet resistance, do you wish you had your old job back.
- A cited study shows that leaders often fail because they are put in positions that require working closely with others, while few people learn early how to cooperate, listen with empathy and confront respectfully.
- Conclusion: anyone in a position of influence needs communication and conflict resolution skills.
The title comes first, the team comes later
Michelle Adams's piece borrows the very idea that opens the L.E.T.® book. In Chapter 1, Dr. Thomas Gordon writes that a leader can shape a group or destroy it, and that if leadership turns into a bad experience, it is almost always because of the leader's own ineffectiveness. He is also fair in saying that very few people have ever been properly trained for this. The research he cites shows that leaders often fail because they are placed in positions that require close cooperation with others, yet they do not know how to work with them as equal partners.
What happens after the appointment
Chapter 2 has a title I really like: holding a leadership position does not mean you are already a leader. Gordon is quite candid about what new leaders typically face. Some people are jealous, and some resent you because they think they deserved the job. Friends from just a few weeks ago now avoid you and stop inviting you to lunch. Some become guarded and defensive, some flatter you openly, and some stubbornly resist every new plan.
He explains this with the idea of the "inner child of the past" in each of us. From childhood, everyone lives under the power of parents, teachers and coaches, and every child tries many ways of coping. Whatever works becomes a habit and is carried into adulthood. Gordon lists fourteen mechanisms, from resisting, lying and forming alliances to submitting, flattering and withdrawing.
The thing to remember is that you did not create these reactions, you only inherited them. The group was ready to cope with you before you had used any power at all.
What people gain by accepting you
So what turns someone with a title into a real leader? Gordon says the turning point in leadership research came when social scientists began to see leadership as an interaction, in which the members themselves decide whether to accept or reject the influence of the person in charge. People join a group to meet their own needs, and they accept direction only from someone they trust will help them meet those needs.
But leaders have needs too, including the need to be valued by their own superiors. Gordon calls this a dilemma: one hand looks after productivity for the organization, the other looks after the members' needs. He writes that an effective leader cannot be good only at human relations, nor only at productivity, but must have both sets of skills and know when to use which.
The temptation to do it all yourself
Chapter 3 is about a trap I see in a great many new managers: wanting to prove quickly that they deserve the job, they rush to solve every problem themselves. Gordon points out that every group resists change and clings to old norms, such as an unspoken standard of "a fair day's work" that everyone understands. A newcomer who brings many changes is easily seen as upsetting the balance between effort and reward, and the group will defend itself.
Then comes over-supervision: demanding detailed reports, requiring approval before every decision, and taking employees' work back to do it "right".
An example: Khoa, a skilled technician, is promoted to lead a maintenance team of nine. In the first month, whenever a machine has a tough breakdown, he goes down and fixes it himself, because he fixes things faster than anyone. By the third month, the team calls him for every breakdown, even the easy ones, and he has no time left for the maintenance plan the director is waiting for. He is building his own skills while slowly tearing down his team's capability.
Fixing things better than everyone else is why you were promoted, but it is not why people will let you lead them.
One person changes, the whole plant notices
The good news lies in a University of Chicago study that Gordon cites in Chapter 1, which followed a single plant manager who learned the L.E.T.® skills. A year later, researchers held in-depth interviews with the 11 foremen in his group and with top management. Of 160 comments about him, only five could be read as criticism. At the top of the list was being a good listener, with 27 comments, and 11 comments mentioned higher output and profit.
The four questions in the original article, about whether you find this role worth doing and whether you wish you had your old job back, are an honest test. If your answers lean toward exhaustion, Gordon's view suggests that what is missing is skill, and skill can be learned.
Reflection questions
- Since your promotion, who on the team has changed how they behave toward you, and which coping mechanism is it?
- Last week, how many tasks that belong to your team did you take back to do yourself?
- If you asked your team why they accept your leadership, what do you think they would say besides "because you're the boss"?
Collaboration, empathic listening and respectful confrontation can all be learned. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, teaches exactly these skills to people who have just been given a team.
This skill can be learned
An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.



