Summary of the original
People who are new to Active Listening often get an eye roll or a sigh. The article gives two causes: using it at the wrong time, and using one opening phrase too often.
What the original article says
- Wrong timing: you use Active Listening when the other person's behavior is below the Acceptance Line. At that point the listener is usually annoyed or afraid, and an I-Message is the right response. People can sense this mismatch.
- An overused opening phrase: when every response starts with "It sounds like…", the other person spots the technique and feels "handled".
- If you genuinely want to understand and their behavior is above the Acceptance Line, people usually forgive you for sounding a bit mechanical. Say openly that you are practicing to become a better listener.
- Two things to remember before using it: you can never truly become the other person, so your feedback should be tentative, letting them confirm or correct it.
- The article suggests many different openings, for when you are keeping up with the speaker and for when you are struggling to.
The eye roll has a reason
People new to Active Listening often run into exactly the scene in the title. You say "it sounds like you're...", and the other person sighs or rolls their eyes. Michelle Adams's article points to two causes: using it at the wrong time, and overusing one opening phrase. I find the first cause more worth discussing, because it is not about wording but about not yet having worked out who has the problem.
The wrong side of the Acceptance Line
In the L.E.T.® book, Dr. Thomas Gordon uses the Behavior Window to divide other people's behavior into two sides of the Acceptance Line. Above it is behavior you can accept. When a team member is sad, confused or upset about something in their own life, that is their problem, and Active Listening fits. Below it is behavior that is causing you a problem, and then the problem is yours.
In Chapter 6, Gordon puts the two roles side by side. When the other person has the problem, you are the listener, the one who helps them find their own solution, and you can accept their solution even if you are not entirely satisfied. When you have the problem, you are the speaker and the influencer, you must be satisfied with the solution, and you need to be more assertive. The tool for the second role is the I-Message: describe the behavior without blame, state your real feelings, and name the concrete effect on you.
Listening while you are annoyed yourself means hiding your real feelings behind a layer of technique. Gordon says it bluntly in Chapter 4: if you do not truly feel accepting while the other person is sharing, no listening skill will ever cover up your real feelings. People sense the mismatch between words and tone, and the eye roll is a reaction to that mismatch.
An illustration: Bình, a waiter at a restaurant, is late for the third time this week, and Lan, the shift supervisor, has to cover for him during the rush. She is annoyed but remembers what she learned, so she says, "It sounds like you've been under a lot of pressure lately." Bình rolls his eyes. The right sentence at that moment is an I-Message: when you start your shift late, I have to leave the counter to wait tables in your place, customers wait a long time, and I feel very stressed.
Listening is not a polite way to avoid telling the truth.
Shifting gears in both directions
Speaking honestly does not mean you stop listening. Gordon writes that common reactions to an I-Message are worry, defensiveness, apology or pushback. At that point it is the other person who has the problem, and you need Shifting Gears: set your own message aside to listen to them, and only then return to your needs.
Gordon quotes the account of a company president hired from outside, who faced a senior vice president who often arrived late, looked at his watch and sighed in meetings. The president voiced his discomfort, got pushback, then switched to listening. The more he listened, the more the real story came out: the vice president felt the company should have considered someone from inside, and felt unwelcome because he tended to speak his mind. After that conversation he attended meetings regularly and took a more active part, and he was later promoted to executive vice president. The two skills here do not rule each other out. They take turns within the same conversation.
The opening phrase is not the skill
The second cause is easier to fix. The core of Active Listening, according to Chapter 4, is feeding back what you understood so the speaker can confirm or correct it. Gordon gives the example of a speaker replying that they are more angry than discouraged. That correction is as valuable as a confirmation, because it tells you that you had misunderstood.
In other words, what your sentence needs is the other person's feelings and meaning, while the opening phrase is just the wrapper. Gordon's own examples change the wrapper all the time: one starts with "You're really stuck", another goes straight to the speaker's disappointment about a meeting. Everyday speech offers many more natural options, such as "So you feel...", "You must be...", "You're worried that...". He also says we can never be completely sure we have understood someone correctly, so feedback should sound like a guess they can correct, not like a verdict.
And if the other person's behavior is above the Acceptance Line and you genuinely want to understand, people usually forgive you for sounding a bit mechanical. Gordon himself admits that when he was first learning, the new ways of speaking felt forced and mechanical. Just tell your team that you are practicing to listen better, and the eye roll may turn into a smile.
Reflection questions
- The last time you used Active Listening, was the problem your team member's or yours?
- Do you use the same opening phrase for every response?
- Is there something you are annoyed about that you have not yet put into a clear I-Message?
Telling when to listen and when to speak, then switching smoothly between the two, is the part that needs practice with an observer. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, has practice sessions for exactly this.
This skill can be learned
An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.



