Conflict and resistanceI-Message

That's a lot of resistance, isn't it?

Read the article

Summary of the original

Defensiveness is a very natural first reaction when we feel threatened, and it takes a lot of energy. The article covers how to handle resistance in others, how to accept resistance in yourself, the signs to look for, and how to turn resistance into useful information.

Original article · 01

What the original article says

  1. When others resist you, responding in kind usually escalates into an argument or silence, the problem goes unsolved and the relationship suffers.
  2. In yourself, resistance is a signal that something needs to change. We tend to cling to the familiar because it seems safer.
  3. Anger is often a secondary emotion covering disappointment, fear or hurt, like the tip of an iceberg.
  4. Indirect resistance includes forgetting agreements, feigning confusion, procrastinating, quiet sabotage, avoidance, withdrawal and punishing silence. Physical signs include a flushed face, sweating, avoiding eye contact and fidgeting.
  5. How to use this: with others, listen with acceptance and empathy; with yourself, notice what triggers your defensiveness and listen to that signal.
Perspective · 02

Defensiveness is a reflex, not a character flaw

Linda Adams opens her post with something easy to forget when you are annoyed: defensiveness is a very natural first reaction when we feel threatened. A defensive person is not necessarily trying to oppose you. They are protecting something, and your job is to find out what it is.

The L.E.T.® book by Dr. Thomas Gordon explains the roots of this reflex. In Chapter 4, he writes that people do not solve problems well when they feel threatened, judged, belittled or analyzed in order to force them to change. Such an environment breeds defensiveness and resistance, because the person is holding on to their need for safety, the second level of Maslow's hierarchy of needs.

Perspective · 03

Resistance is learned very early

In Chapter 2, Gordon says every adult carries an "inner child of the past". As children, everyone had to cope with people in authority, and whatever worked became a habit. Among the fourteen mechanisms he lists are opposing, lying and hiding feelings, forming alliances, withdrawing, and even getting sick.

Put this next to the list of indirect resistance in the original post, such as forgetting agreements, pretending not to understand, procrastinating or punishing silence, and you will see they share the same root. People did not invent these tactics in this morning's meeting. They were using them long before they met you.

Gordon also points out in Chapter 3 that every group resists change, especially change imposed from the top down. In Chapter 5, he adds a reason few people notice: learning something new means giving up familiar ways of working, and the learner's role easily brings back the feeling of being pushed around by teachers at school. So remarks like "I've always done it this way" or "What's wrong with the old way?" are often apprehension, not necessarily opposition.

Perspective · 04

When the other person pushes back

Even a skillfully delivered I-Message can be met with pushback. Gordon writes in Chapter 6 that the usual reactions of a person asked to change are anxiety, defensiveness, hurt or resistance.

Responding in the same tone, as the original post warns, pushes both sides into an argument or silence. Gordon points to another path, Shifting Gears: set your own needs aside for a moment, use Active Listening to hear out the other person's defensiveness fully, and only then restate what you need. In Chapter 9, he adds that a person who has not had a chance to vent their feelings will not be ready to look for solutions with you.

An illustration: Thảo, head of the accounting department, moves the whole department to new software. Hùng, who has kept the books in spreadsheets for years, keeps "forgetting" to enter data. She tells him clearly that because he has not entered the data, she cannot close the month-end figures, and he argues that the software is confusing and wastes time. She shifts to listening, and after a few exchanges the real issue comes out: he is afraid of making entry mistakes in front of the younger staff, who are more comfortable with computers than he is. The problem is not the software but the pride of someone who is good at his job.

Perspective · 05

Feelings are signals

The original post compares anger to the tip of an iceberg, with disappointment, fear or hurt hidden underneath. Gordon looks in the same direction when he writes in Chapter 5 that leaders should treat feelings as "friends". A group member's feelings are like pain in the body, signaling that something is going wrong.

He also holds that strong feelings usually pass quickly if they are received. He quotes an industrial relations director at an American chemical company describing the time the union president stormed into his office in anger, face flushed, then stood up to walk out. As the man was nearly at the door, the director raised his voice slightly and said that he was clearly very upset about this. The man stopped, came back, sat down and talked for five more minutes, and left less tense, even though the problem remained.

Resistance is the other person telling the truth in the language they have used since childhood.

Perspective · 06

And your own resistance

The original post reminds us that we tend to cling to the familiar because it seems safer. In Chapter 12, Gordon makes an observation worth turning on yourself: people who cannot listen to others are often defensive, because they refuse to face opinions different from their own. Real listening carries a risk, because if you truly understand someone, you may have to change how you see things. Next time you feel your face getting hot at a piece of feedback, ask yourself what is being threatened.

Perspective · 07

Reflection questions

  1. In your team, what form is resistance taking: open argument, forgetting, procrastination or silence?
  2. Was the most recent change you introduced discussed with the team, or announced to them?
  3. The last time you got defensive about feedback, what in you was being threatened?

Hearing someone else's defensiveness without getting defensive yourself is a skill best practiced with a guide. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, gives you enough time for that.

This skill can be learned

An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.

Read next

All articles