New leaders

Do we really need leaders?

Read the article

Summary of the original

According to the article, a group leader's core job is to help the group solve problems and resolve conflicts. A group that always works effectively, whose members feel engaged and valued, needs very little supervision. Leadership becomes essential when members' needs are not met, when the group is not reaching the organization's goals, or when unresolved personal conflicts get in the way of cooperation.

Original article · 01

What the original article says

  1. Effective leaders need specific communication and conflict resolution skills to become people who encourage cooperation, trust, respect and productivity.
  2. Leaders must take on two roles: "productivity specialist" (meeting the organization's needs) and "human relations specialist" (meeting group members' needs and helping the parties resolve conflicts). Without one role, the other does not work well either.
  3. Note: the article is promotional; its claims about Gordon's training program are stated without supporting evidence.
Perspective · 02

A question that sounds provocative

Michelle Adams's article asks a question that makes any manager a little uneasy: do we really need leaders? The article's answer is yes, but not for the reason people usually think. The article also reads as a promotion for Gordon's program, so I checked it against the L.E.T.® book to see what the original argument stands on.

Perspective · 03

No problems, little need for a boss

In Chapter 2, Dr. Thomas Gordon treats the main function of a group leader as facilitating problem solving. He argues that a group that always works effectively, whose members always feel accomplished, connected and valued, will rarely need a "supervisor". A group truly needs a leader when members have trouble meeting their needs, or when the group is not reaching the organization's goals.

I find that this view lifts an unreasonable pressure off managers. A week in which your team runs smoothly does not mean you are redundant; it means the hard-to-see part of your job is being done well, and that is the time to prepare for when problems arrive.

Perspective · 04

Three kinds of problems, three sets of skills

Gordon uses the Behavior Window to divide problems into three kinds. Sometimes the employee owns the problem, for example they are worried, irritated or discouraged about something of their own. Sometimes you own the problem, because their behavior is getting in the way of your work. Sometimes you both own it, when the two sides' needs collide. In the middle is the No-Problem Area, where work runs smoothly and both of you feel your needs are being met.

According to Gordon, the leader's job is to widen that middle area, that is, to increase the time spent working productively. But the three kinds of problems need three kinds of skills: listening so the other person can work through their own problem, speaking plainly to meet your own needs, and resolving conflicts so that no one loses. He also admits that no leader can solve every problem on the team; it is an ideal to aim for, and he has not seen any organization achieve it.

Perspective · 05

Two roles, and missing one breaks both

Adams's article mentions two roles, and the book explains them in more depth. Right in Chapter 1, Gordon recalls the long-running debate over whether a boss should be people-oriented or task-oriented. His answer is that research shows effective leaders must be both a "human relations specialist" and a "task specialist", and that lacking either one leads to ineffectiveness. In Chapter 2 he describes two sets of skills: one helps members feel valued and connected to the group, the other helps the group reach its goals through planning, scheduling, coordinating, problem solving and securing resources.

In Chapter 11 he adds a line that "kind-hearted" managers should read: treating people well, meeting their needs and removing sources of dissatisfaction are not, on their own, enough for high productivity and performance. And in Chapter 2, Gordon sums up the logic of the two roles in a single idea: members want to be on a winning team, but never at the cost of their own sense of worth.

A team does not need a boss who solves every problem alone. It needs someone who makes sure no problem is left unfinished.

Perspective · 06

Making sure problems get solved

In Chapter 3, Gordon has a very concise heading: do not solve problems yourself, make sure problems get solved. A leader who is proud that no problem ever slips out of their hands will end up running a one-man show, with a dependent team that has never practiced solving problems. Gordon wants the leader to guide a six-step process: define the problem, generate alternative solutions, evaluate them, make a decision, implement it, then follow up on the results. At the first step, the team can often help a great deal, because the leader is often the last to notice a problem.

An illustration: Phong, a technical team lead at a software company in Hanoi, is liked by the whole team because he never snaps at anyone. But he avoids reminding people about deadlines. Three deliveries go out late, the client complains, and the strongest people on the team start to lose heart because their work is buried in a project that gets criticized. Phong does one role well and leaves the other empty, and the team does not thank him for it.

Perspective · 07

Reflection questions

  1. Last week, how much time did you spend fixing problems yourself, and how much helping others fix them?
  2. If you asked your team, would they say you lean toward the people role or the task role?
  3. Which problem is sitting on your desk that someone on your team could actually solve better?

Each role calls for its own set of skills, and few people are born with both. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, is where you practice both, so your team needs you for the right reasons.

This skill can be learned

An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.

Read next

All articles