Summary of the original
When you are promoted, your group members' relationship with you changes. Former colleagues or friends now see you as "above" them, and may react with suspicion, distrust, hostility, subservience or hidden resistance. These reactions come from the ways of coping with authority they learned as children. The leader does not create them, but inherits them.
What the original article says
Fourteen learned coping mechanisms (grouped for easier reading)
- Fighting back: resisting, rebelling, resentment, hostility, aggression, retaliation, ridicule, forming alliances against others.
- Hiding and blaming: lying, hiding feelings, blaming, tattling, cheating.
- Dominating or needing to win: bullying those with less power, needing to win, hating to lose, perfectionism.
- Submitting: obeying, being servile, flattering, conforming, fearing new ideas, depending on those in power.
- Avoiding: withdrawing, escaping, daydreaming, regressing, getting sick, crying.
Conclusion. A title does not bring leadership by itself. The central argument of the book: being "the one in charge" does not mean you are already a leader. Leaders must learn specific skills and methods to be accepted by the group and have a positive influence.
The new leader's temptation
The question in the title of Dr. Thomas Gordon's post sounds simple, but many newly promoted people answer it by rolling up their sleeves, taking control, and proving they deserve the role. In Chapter 3 of the L.E.T.® book, Gordon calls this the new leader's temptation: wanting quick reforms, instant solutions, and a clean sweep of whatever the predecessor left behind. He points out that leaders rarely manage any of this without the team's goodwill and cooperation, and neither is available right away.
The reason is that every group has its own unwritten norms about what counts as a fair day's work, and how much effort is worth the pay. A newcomer bringing many changes is easily seen as upsetting that balance, and the group will react to protect itself, especially when new ways of working are imposed from the top down.
Chapter 2 also mentions the people who hoped to be chosen for your position. They may now feel envious or resentful, because in their eyes they were the ones who deserved it.
Don't become a watchdog
Gordon describes a type of new leader who is very enthusiastic and very harmful: the overly vigilant supervisor, who believes no mistake can happen because they keep a grip on everything. He describes four forms: demanding detailed reports on every activity; requiring approval before sending contracts, making plans or taking decisions; taking work back from employees to make sure it is done "right"; and requiring every outside contact to go through them.
The consequences he lists follow one another like links in a chain. The team gets annoyed at what feels like arbitrary use of power, then resists passively, for example the activity reports somehow never get submitted. Worse, they become dependent, bringing every question upward, and initiative slowly dies out. The leader, meanwhile, is overloaded from doing everything alone, and by the time they realize they are on their own, it is too late.
In the first three months, your job is not to prove you are better than the team, but to show the team what they gain by working with you.
With old friends, narrow the status gap
Gordon sees narrowing the status gap between the leader and group members as key to building a team that works well. He advises avoiding displays of power such as condescension, arrogance and arbitrary use of authority, because people with less power tend to keep their distance from people with more. He describes a paradox: while the boss stays in a high position, the boss's ideas are easily accepted without scrutiny, or rejected just because they come from the boss, and both make the team worse. Only when you are seen almost as an ordinary member will your ideas be weighed on their actual merit.
With old friends, this means something concrete: don't change your tone just because your title changed. The way you address each other, the lunches and the old jokes don't need to go. You just need to be clear about the matters that belong to your new role.
Caught in the middle, be the linking pin
In Chapter 2, Gordon names the bind: a leader in an organization must meet the organization's need for productivity while also meeting the team's needs, and the team sometimes resists that very pressure for productivity. He acknowledges that leaders also need to be valued by their superiors, and that if they fall short of expectations they may be demoted or lose their jobs.
Chapter 3 offers an easier way to see it. In the organization, you are a linking pin: the leader of your own team, and at the same time a member of your boss's team. One of the tasks Gordon sets for the linking pin is to advocate strongly for their people in the team above. He also makes clear that the leader is accountable to the organization for the group's results, and that involving the team in decisions does not lighten that responsibility.
An illustrative example
Huy was promoted to lead a seven-person design team at an advertising agency in Ho Chi Minh City, which included Nga, who had also applied for the role. In the first month, Huy changed no processes and simply met each person privately to ask what was getting in their way. In the second month, he took three obstacles the whole team had raised to a meeting with his boss and got two of them resolved. In the third month, he asked Nga to lead the work of standardizing the template library, something she was better at than he was. Not everyone came around right away, but the team began to see that Huy's position made their work lighter.
Reflection questions
- In your first month, what did you change without asking the team a single question?
- Which decisions are you approving that people on your team could make on their own?
- When was the last time you spoke up for your team in front of your superiors?
Getting promoted is the easy part; becoming a leader the team accepts is the part you have to learn. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, is where new managers practice those skills before old habits set in.
This skill can be learned
An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.



