Active ListeningProblem Ownership

How does empathy affect business results?

Read the article

Summary of the original

When the problem belongs to the other person, the right skills are Basic Listening and Active Listening. The author sees these as the hardest skills for most people to learn, and also the most powerful. The article argues that an empathic environment helps people become psychologically healthier, solve problems better and get more of their needs met.

Original article · 01

What the original article says

  1. Empathy is the ability to put yourself in another person's place and understand their "private world of meanings". Active Listening serves exactly this purpose.
  2. Five arguments for those who still hesitate: it keeps ownership of the solution with the other person; people who solve their own problems become more capable and independent; they have more information than an outsider; if your solution fails, you are responsible; and if your solution succeeds, it does not build their confidence and it takes time away from your own work.
  3. The cost of not listening: when needs go unmet, people lose focus, spend time venting frustration, make mistakes, lose motivation and talk less with their leaders.
Perspective · 02

The question from people with targets to hit

When I talk about empathy with managers, I am almost certain to hear the question: "Sounds nice, but where's the money in it?" It is a fair question, because middle managers are measured by output, sales and deadlines, and nobody gives them credit for spending half an hour listening to an employee.

Michelle Adams's post answers with the cost of not listening. I go one step further, into how Dr. Thomas Gordon links empathy to productivity in the core model of the L.E.T.® book.

Perspective · 03

Real working time

Gordon uses the Behavior Window to divide the moments in a relationship between a boss and an employee into four areas: the employee has a problem, the boss has a problem, both have a problem, and the No-Problem Area. Only in the last area does work run smoothly. From there he redefines the leader's role: to maximize productive work time while making sure the needs of both sides are met.

Seen this way, an employee who is upset inside is not in the work area, even while sitting in the right seat with the right screen open. The costs the original post lists, from losing focus to no longer talking to the boss, are exactly that lost time. Under Problem Ownership, the problem belongs to the employee, but its cost sits on your payroll.

Perspective · 04

Suppressed feelings don't disappear

Gordon writes plainly that the norm "feelings have no place at work" harms both health and effectiveness: feelings held in for a long time can turn into stomach ulcers, headaches and high blood pressure, and in the short term they make people lose focus.

He tells of a teacher who gets through the school days with three Martinis before dinner, while a sales director has a neater way to survive: keep your opinions to yourself. I find the second way more frightening. A manager who has decided to stay silent still comes to work every day, but no longer brings any ideas or warnings to the meeting table, and no report records that loss.

Perspective · 05

Three stories from the book

Gordon cites many real stories from organizations that have taken L.E.T.®, and I picked three with clear business consequences.

  • An engineer at a construction company in Canada, only two weeks after taking L.E.T.®, was sent to a dam site that had seen too many accidents, where a few years earlier worker discontent had caused millions of dollars in losses. About 80 workers sat waiting in the cafeteria, and the atmosphere was very tense. He used Active Listening for two hours, then listened for several more hours after lunch. According to the book, conflict, work stoppages and injuries all went down.
  • A human resources director said that for twenty years, management gave in whenever union officials shouted loudly enough, to the point of losing many things that should have been kept. After the course, he wrote down each of their points and reflected back their feelings. They calmed down, and were still satisfied with how things were handled even when the answer was not what they wanted. This is an American setting with unions, but "whoever shouts loudest wins" happens in every workplace.
  • A supervisor was assigned an employee everyone found difficult, and at first even thought the man needed psychological treatment. After listening for a while, the supervisor found what triggered the outbursts, and the two came to work well together. Gordon draws a conclusion I really like: people are more likable than we think, once we understand why they act the way they do.
Perspective · 06

Nancy's half hour

The book has a dialogue between Kate, a supervisor, and Nancy, whom Kate goes to for advice on handling a young employee who rejects every suggestion. Nancy has half an hour before a meeting, and throughout the conversation she only reflects Kate's feelings, without giving a single piece of advice. Kate arrives on her own at the decision to hold a team meeting the following week, then thanks Nancy and goes back to work. Nancy does not have to take any extra work back to her desk.

An illustration: Quang, the warehouse manager, notices that young Tài keeps making mistakes when preparing orders lately. Instead of reminding him once more, Quang spends fifteen minutes listening. It turns out Tài has been put on the night shift three weeks in a row and is reluctant to ask for a change for fear of looking picky. Changing the shift costs Quang one phone call, while the wrong orders have already cost the warehouse several rounds of redelivery.

Listening does not take work time away from the team. It gives back the time that quiet frustration has been eating up.

Perspective · 07

Reflection questions

  1. This week, how many hours did your team lose to frustrations no one voiced?
  2. Who on your team has stopped bringing ideas to meetings, and since when?
  3. The last time you gave advice, did the other person have to come back with more questions?

Listening to protect productivity is a skill you can practice, not a personality trait. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, lets you practice it in class and then try it right away with your team.

This skill can be learned

An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.

Read next

All articles