Summary of the original
Many people avoid confrontation because of bad past experiences, usually with You-Messages. The article argues that I-Messages carry far less risk because they are about the speaker, not the listener, and explains how to confront at the right time and in the right way.
What the original article says
- Stay Current: speak up as soon as something happens, and avoid "gunny sacking" (storing up frustrations and dumping them all at once).
- When met with a defensive reaction, people trained in L.E.T.® know how to use Shifting Gears.
- A behavior is something you can observe and measure, the way a video camera records it. Traits such as "rude" or "thoughtless" are not behaviors.
- Example: "When you talk loudly, I can't concentrate" is more likely to get someone to change than "You are rude and thoughtless."
- Conclusion: if you want effective working relationships, confront in the least risky, most respectful and most honest way.
The hesitation has a reason
Michelle Adams's piece opens with something true: many people shy away from confrontation because of bad past experiences. In Chapter 6 of the L.E.T.® book, Dr. Thomas Gordon does not treat that hesitation as weakness either. Everyone feels uneasy telling someone that their behavior is causing a problem, for fear the other person will be hurt, get angry or stop liking them, and in his view the fear is well founded: people who are confronted often argue back, criticize in return or walk away.
Gordon adds one more reason that I find very true: the language we use to confront was learned from the very adults who scolded us as children. In L.E.T.® classes, participants get a scenario in which Ann keeps interrupting people in meetings, and are asked what they would say to her. In every class, almost every answer falls into the twelve Roadblocks to Communication: ordering, threatening, moralizing, praising before criticizing, labeling her a "know-it-all". We hesitate to speak partly because the only way we know how to speak is the very way most likely to make things worse.
The cost of holding it in
Gordon is also clear about the cost of silence: the problem is rarely solved, and the leader either puts up with it or slowly builds resentment. In Chapter 8 he goes further: the resentment builds up, and a few months later some small incident sets it off, far more fiercely than that incident deserves. The feelings also get carried home as nagging, and inside the organization they turn into a climate of grumbling and talking behind people's backs.
The original article gives this habit its proper name, gunny sacking: stuffing frustrations into a sack and then dumping them out all at once. The advice that goes with it is Stay Current: speak up as soon as the thing happens, while it is still small and specific and the other person still remembers it.
Talk about yourself, describe the behavior
Gordon calls the familiar confronting statements You-Messages, because every one of them zeroes in on the listener. He gives three reasons they usually fail. People do not like being told what to do, so they dig in. They blame, when people rarely know they are causing anyone trouble and are simply looking after their own needs. And they point in the wrong place, because the person with the problem is you, yet the statement says nothing about you.
An I-Message fixes all three. A complete message has three parts: a brief, blameless description of the behavior; your honest feeling; and the concrete effect on your work. Gordon notes that stating only the feeling is not enough, because the listener will be confused and ask what they did.
The hard part is describing behavior. The original article uses the image of a video camera: only what a camera can record counts as behavior. Talking loudly in the office is a behavior, while "rude" and "thoughtless" are labels, and L.E.T.® calls this kind of label a GLOP (a general label put on a person). Labels keep people busy defending their character instead of thinking about how to change one specific action.
One of Gordon's points was a relief to me: you do not need to understand why the other person acts that way before you are allowed to speak up. In his confrontation model, the leader only needs to understand their own feelings and state them without criticism. Many people keep putting it off because they are waiting to fully understand another human being, which almost never happens.
When the other person gets defensive
A well-formed I-Message can still be met with an argument, and Gordon sees that as normal. At this point, people trained in L.E.T.® use Shifting Gears: they set their own message aside, switch to Active Listening to hear out the other person's reaction, and only then state their message again.
The book tells of a company president hired from outside who had a senior vice president who often came late, looked at the clock and sighed in meetings. The president held it in until he could no longer, then spoke up, and the vice president argued that he was not the only one responsible for the meeting. The president shifted to listening, and layer after layer came out: the vice president was tired of always having to be the one with the ideas, and felt the company should have considered an insider for the president's chair. After that he attended meetings regularly and took a more active part, and he was later promoted to executive vice president.
An example: Ngân, head of administration, tells Phong in accounting: "When the timesheets come in after 10 a.m. on Monday, I can't get them signed before the weekly briefing, and I'm worried the whole company's payroll will be late." Phong shoots back: "My team has to wait for the units to send theirs in too." She shifts gears: "You're stuck too, because the units send theirs late." He nods and explains that two production units always send theirs at the last minute, and the two of them agree to move the units' deadline up to Friday afternoon.
The hardest thing to say is usually the thing you should say soonest, while it is still small and you are still calm enough.
Reflection questions
- Is there something you have been holding in for more than two weeks without saying it?
- The last time you gave feedback, did you describe the behavior or label the person?
- When the other person argues back, do you keep arguing or shift to listening?
Knowing the three-part formula is easy; saying it while your heart is racing is hard. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, lets you practice confronting and shifting gears with real people before you have to do it at work.
This skill can be learned
An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.



