New leadersL.E.T.® history

Is L.E.T.® too "soft"?

Read the article

Summary of the original

When the L.E.T.® program officially launched in 1977, many people called it "soft" and too employee-centered. The article looks back at those criticisms and argues that the program is still taught around the world today because the relationship skills L.E.T.® teaches are increasingly seen as essential for leaders.

Original article · 01

What the original article says

  1. The early criticisms: managers holding many group meetings, sharing power with group members, trusting the "wisdom of the group", and Active Listening seen as psychotherapy brought into the workplace.
  2. The skills the author says new leaders need: running participative meetings, Active Listening, I-Messages, resolving conflicts so both sides get their needs met, and recognizing the Roadblocks.
  3. Conclusion: L.E.T.® teaches people to get along better, and that is good for business.
  4. Historical note: in 1955 Gordon published "Group-Centered Leadership", the foundation of L.E.T.®
Perspective · 02

The criticism came earlier

Michelle Adams's article recalls that when the L.E.T.® program officially launched in 1977, many people dismissed it as "soft", too centered on employees. Reading the afterword of the L.E.T.® book, I found that the criticism is even older than the program. Dr. Thomas Gordon writes that in 1955 he published his first book, Group-Centered Leadership, and his colleagues in the field hardly read it. He guessed that perhaps the book was poor, perhaps the model was not yet complete, or, as he came to believe later, it was too far ahead of its time.

What were those ideas that went too far? That leaders should not use power, should invite the group to make major decisions together, can trust the wisdom of the group, should narrow the status gap with their people, and that rewards and punishment are not effective motivators. Gordon writes that these views have since become mainstream thinking about organizational leadership, and research has confirmed many of them.

Perspective · 03

Soft mistaken for permissive

In Chapter 8, Gordon explains where the criticism comes from. Opponents of the human relations school often equated it with Method II, the way of resolving conflict in which the employee wins and the leader loses. They called it soft management and permissive leadership.

Interestingly, Gordon half agrees with them: permissiveness really is harmful. Leaders who give in on everything to keep employees happy end up resentful, take their frustration home, and eventually have a team that does little and has no commitment to the work. He compares it to permissive parents and to overly permissive classrooms where almost no teaching or learning takes place. In his view, many people slide into permissiveness only because it seems less bad than being authoritarian, without knowing there is a third option.

That third option is Method III, the No-Lose Method, in which the needs of both sides must be met. In this method the leader does not lose either. Calling it soft is wrong by definition.

Perspective · 04

L.E.T.® asks you to speak up

Read the book closely and the "hard" part takes up a lot of space. In Chapter 6, Gordon writes about leaders who lack assertiveness and will not confront anyone: problems rarely get solved, and they suffer in silence or build up resentment. He himself calls this acceptance of an unfair relationship permissive. That is why the I-Message is taught as an assertive skill: say clearly which behavior is causing you a problem, how you feel, and how it concretely affects your work.

In the final chapter, Gordon also talks about risk. Saying what you really think means letting others know who you are. Really listening means accepting that your own views might change. In his view, communicating this way takes inner security and courage, and I have not seen any "soft" skill that asks so much courage of the learner.

An illustration: Tuấn, a shift leader at a garment factory, sees himself as easygoing. When workers ask to leave early, he lets them. When they ask to swap shifts, he swaps. When someone's delivery runs late, he quietly stays behind to make up for it. Three months later he is exhausted, snaps at home, and starts speaking harshly at shift handovers. His team is surprised that such a gentle man has become so difficult lately. He does not lack firmness. He lacks a way to state his own needs early, before they turn into anger.

Perspective · 05

Evidence from a factory

Gordon also cites a study carried out at the University of Chicago that followed a single plant manager who had learned L.E.T.® skills. One year after he changed his leadership style, researchers conducted in-depth interviews with the 11 foremen under him and the entire top management group. Of 160 separate comments about him, only five could be read as pointing to something undesirable. On impact, 21 comments said cooperation between departments had increased, 11 said output and profit had risen, and 4 said efficiency had gone up and costs had come down.

Gordon admits this data is subjective, even though it was collected by an independent organization. I think that is exactly why it is more credible than an advertisement. In Chapter 1, he states clearly that an effective leader must be good with both people and tasks, and lacking either one leads to poor results.

L.E.T.® does not tell you to be nicer. It asks you both to hear others and to dare to state your own needs honestly.

Perspective · 06

Reflection questions

  1. When there is a conflict, which way do you tend to lean: winning with authority, or giving in to keep the peace?
  2. Is there a need of yours at work that you have kept to yourself for too long?
  3. If your team were interviewed like the people at that factory, what words would they use to describe you?

Soft or tough, the clearest answer comes from trying it yourself. An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu, is where you practice both halves, listening and speaking directly, before taking them back to your team.

This skill can be learned

An L.E.T.® class, part of the program developed by Gordon Training International and represented in Vietnam by VIA Edu: 2 or 3 days in person, practicing skills through real work situations.

Read next

All articles